QUOTE(bigtom @ Nov 2 2009, 03:22 PM)

I really do not think medicare is going to last much longer...Just google medicare and collapse and you get pages and pages of links!
But here is a good question..Why didn't Obama frame this as "Medicare for all"?
No politico in his right mind would want to be perceived as anti medicare.
As long as both sides are bought and paid for we are screwed!
With regard to the viability of Medicare... it is ultimately going to come back to paying for it one way or another... and ultimately there is going to be a day of reckoning for the healthcare industry. Cost control and regulations are coming one way or another, and it would seem that it would be better to take incremental steps now rather than waiting until the whole train derails.
I would think that raising the Medicare tax a slight amount would take care of the problem... since the Medicare tax is only 1.45% for employees and 1.45% for employers. Even doubling that tax would not be an exhorbitant increase but would probably slowly but surely bring financial stability back to Medicare.
And... I agree with your assessment and suggestion where the proper framing of this should have been.
IMHO... Medicare for all is exactly what the system should be. And then, as with anyone on Medicare, they can resort to private insurance if they want to and also for supplemental coverage... but at least the basic need is met.
And... until we get rid of the paid for Congress... nothing will be solved.
Dems Republicans... makes no difference. All the same.... just a matter of degree and certain issues, but the bottom line is they are all puppets.