QUOTE
vfguenley -
I would like to hear from all you vets, for the war or against the war?
QUOTE
Abu Beacon -
the most significant question is:
WHY, DID WE GO TO WAR IN IRAQ?
The 2nd most significant question is:
Does anyone really believe we will just leave with nothing to show for our involvement?
My comments are not made to confuse the issue. The original posting was a very straighforward question. I just think we should go a little deeper.
I am a Vietnam Veteran 1968-69, U.S Army... Like John Kerry, I volunteered. And, like John Kerry I saw that the U.S. was not a positive force for good in Vietnam. However, I also witnessed many individual exceptions, because there were a lot of good guys in Vietnam who were a force for good. Those guys accomplished some good things in spite of the foul intentions of Washington D.C. and the corporate conglomerates that were in it only for the Military contracts.
I did not volunteer to go fight communism. I was 18 years old and was politically unconscious. I had my 19th birthday after six months in country. Perhaps I was like some of the young guys in Iraq today – I wanted the adventure - I got it.
…for the war or against the war? Now? I am against it.
But, like Kerry I “voted” for it. And, like Kerry, I was also against “Desert Storm” in 1991.
But, this one… after 9/11… and considering the position we have put ourselves in with our stupid pig-headed dependence on imported oil… I felt we were “damned if did, and damned if we didn’t.”
I admit, I bought into the “shock and awe” B.S. I was still harboring a false belief that we could have won Vietnam if we would have just let the military loose to do its thing. Well, that is exactly what happened in Baghdad on March 20, 2003. We let loose the full Military force of the USA, and what a sight. Exactly what I expected – we won!!!
But, just like Vietnam… we can’t OCCUPY! Without the flowers from the people… we just can’t do it. So, now I got that out of my system. I hadn’t realized how foolish those secret feelings were… If only we let the military do its job… I must need medication, because I was holding those thoughts for over 30 years, while at the same time openly telling people, that because of what I saw in Vietnam, if I had been a South Vietnamese, I would have been a Viet Cong. (Hey guys, am I the only one?)
For years I have been saying the Germans are whores because they allow the U.S. Military to continue keeping bases in their Country. Why? We are told; the U.S. must protect its “National Interests”. Well, then I ask, why don’t we see German, French and Japanese Military bases in the USA protecting “their” national interests? Go figure!
With the help of some good friends, and forums like JohnKerry.com and CGCS I have been able to see all of this more clearly.
I think the biggest problem I had was this… After Nam, I buried it. The day I was discharged from the Army, after I got off the base, I went into a public restroom, changed cloths, and walked over the dumpster and threw in my duffle bag, my military ID, and everything connecting me to the U.S Army. I didn’t talk to anybody about Vietnam until years later when Oliver Stone produced “Platoon”. Too many people were telling me the movie was “anti-American” so I went to see it. Whoever wrote the script was there. It got me thinking about Nam again.
Like I said, I was opposed to Desert Storm, but it did something to me. For the first time in my life I felt “Proud” of our Military. It occurred to me that maybe that was how the WWII generation felt. I liked the feeling. I bought it.
After 9/11 our Nation came together like never before in My Life. Again, that must have been how the WWII generation felt. I liked seeing George Jr. and Tom Daschle hug each other after 9/11. Kind of made me feel like… An American.
So, part of me did not want to let that “group hug” go. I detested George Jr. before 9/11. But, like most Americans, I wanted to “defend” my country. Vietnam was never about “defending” anything – it was a foolish kid’s adventure. This, 9/11, it was real. More real than Pearl Harbor.
Abu Beacon asked: WHY, DID WE GO TO WAR IN IRAQ?I just explained why I “voted” same as Kerry, but now I think the real reason may have been because some “foolish kids” in Washington, D.C. had never experienced the “adventure” of war, so they wanted their turn.
However, I do believe that if the USA were not dependent on foreign oil we would have no “National interests" in the Middle East. There is absolutely no possibility that we will ever “liberate” the Sudan… unless oil is discovered under their sand.