The campus where I teach has just been acquired by corporation to form another On-Line University. I'm sorting out my options. Maybe some of you have some experience with course work or teaching a fast growing segment in higher ed such as Univ. of Phoenix, Kaplan and Capella. If so, would you post your thoughts?
Pros:
Much more accessible to adults working full time, people who are homebound for health reasons, or taking care of small children.
More energy efficient because of much lower commuting costs.
Military personnel stationed oversees can continue their education when they are off-duty.
On-line formats can provide better quality assurance of instruction, since all interactions are written and recorded. That way it is easier to assess students' progress toward course objectives.
Lower costs can be passed onto students and taxpayers.
Asynchronous format allows much greater flexibility in how students and faculty schedule their time.
Faculty are less confined to a geographic location. They can travel all over the world and still continue teaching as long as they can connect to the internet.
Cons:
Faculty are primarily part-time and most have other full time jobs. Seldom are there full-time faculty positions with benefits. This is the main reason for lower costs. It seems to be a kind of outsourcing for teachers in higher ed. Teaching in higher education is being devalued. It's almost impossible to make a living teaching on-line.
On-line education is somewhat of a corporate subsidy for hardware and software industries. Students struggling to get their education have to buy into PCs and software that have rapid cycling planned obsolescence.
Students can get by without developming a basic work ethic and time management habits. They could be up all night at the computer and sleep in the next day. Arriving on time for a meeting and being prepared to give a presentation or participate in deliberations becomes a lost skill.
Students' skills in face to face interaction, speaking, listening, and other "helping" skills can't really be developed in an on-line format.
Students and faculty miss out on real working relationships in real time. It's harder for faculty to be effective as mentors and advocates for the students.
On-line education presents formidable challenges for "click and paste" cheating and plagiarizing.
Teaching on-line courses can be more labor intensive. Faculty not only have to teach and give feedback on course content, but also help students over the learning curve of learning to use software platforms like WebCT and Blackboard.
Electronic monitoring of faculty/student interactions by administrators can present some threats to academic freedom, first amendment rights, and privacy.
I look forward to reading your thoughts.
