SECRECY NEWS
from the FAS Project on Government Secrecy
March 30, 2005
ISRAELI WHISTLEBLOWER VANUNU FACES NEW CHARGES
Mordechai Vanunu, who was released from an Israeli prison last
April after serving 18 years for disclosing secret information on
Israel's nuclear weapons program and who has been seeking to leave
that country, now faces new charges of violating a gag order
prohibiting foreign press interviews.
Y writes from Jerusalem:
"You've probably heard that Mordechai Vanunu has been charged with
violating the restrictions placed on him when he was freed from
prison. The charges list 21 interviews he has given to the foreign
media [...]. The restrictions were due to expire on April 21, but
now the new charges and the pending trial will prevent him from
leaving the country. Mordechai has hired Avigdor Feldman and
Michael Sfard to defend him in this case. (The other day Daniel
Ellsberg, Vanunu's longtime ardent supporter, was here and spoke
at a press conference and on Israeli television. Very
impressive.)"
"I should point out that where the media refer to the restrictions
as the terms of Vanunu's parole, they are mistaken. Vanunu is not
on parole - he served his sentence in full. The restrictions
derive from a British Mandatory state-of-emergency regulation."
"Moreover, not a single word in any of the interviews went further
- in terms of information re Dimona [an Israeli nuclear facility]
etc - than the revelations he made to the Sunday Times in 1986, so
they can hardly be said to affect Israel's security in 2005."
"Some supporters (and Mordechai's brother Meir) advised him to keep
quiet after his release, but Mordechai is not the sort of person
who bends under pressure. I personally think that he was right to
do what he did. If he'd kept shtum [silent] the government could
have said, 'Aha, he's quiet here because he wants to leave, but if
we let him out he'll start giving interviews all over the place
and god knows what he'll say...' - So long as the vindictive
impulse continues to animate the system, Mordechai can't win."
During World War I, Kaiser Wilhelm's Germany sought to curtail
foreign travel by dissidents such as Albert Einstein, among others.
Historian Fritz Stern writes that German authorities imposed the
travel barriers on Einstein because they feared him as "a dangerous
pacifist with international commitments and friendships."
(Einstein's German World, Princeton Univ Press, 1999, p. 116).
IG REPORT ON RESEARCHER ACCESS TO BIOLOGICAL AGENTS
The Bioterrorism Act of 2002 prohibited scientists from gaining
access to particularly hazardous biological agents and toxins
(such as anthrax and Ebola virus) unless they had a legitimate
need for them and had received authorization from the FBI.
A new Justice Department Inspector General (IG) report reviewed the
FBI's "security risk assessment" program for granting such
authorization and found that previous backlogs of researcher
requests had been largely reduced.
Along the way, the IG report provides some new details about the
mechanics of the FBI review process and the number of applications
-- in the thousands -- that the Bureau has received for handling
the restricted biological agents.
"Our inspection showed that the FBI had 3,855 ... Applications
pending in November 2003, but by June 2004, had reduced that
number to 401. The FBI maintained a stable average monthly
caseload of approximately 339 pending ... applications through
December 2004 and was routinely processing the applications in 45
days or less."
A copy of the new IG report, "Inspection of the FBI's Security Risk
Assessment Program for Individuals Requesting Access to Biological
Agents and Toxins," March 2005, may be found here (thanks to
resourceshelf.com):
http://www.fas.org/irp/agency/doj/oig/sra-bio.pdfNASA TO ASSESS IMPACT OF SPACE NUCLEAR REACTORS
If one stood on top of a pile of all of the studies of space
nuclear power that have been performed over the past twenty
years, one would be several feet closer to Mars (at least during
some hours of the day).
Mars will come even closer now that NASA is undertaking a new
programmatic environmental impact statement concerning the
development of nuclear reactors for use in future space missions,
as announced in the Federal Register today:
http://www.fas.org/sgp/news/2005/03/fr033005.htmlAs a technological enterprise, space nuclear reactors have been
subject to a remarkable cycle of boom and bust over the past 50
years, as ambitious programs have been commenced every decade or
so only to be terminated a few years later. The most recent major
space reactor initiative was the SP-100 program, which was
cancelled ten years ago after the expenditure of some $400
million.
The U.S. did launch one space nuclear reactor in 1965; following 43
days of operation, it remains in orbit today. The Soviet Union
launched dozens of nuclear reactors, several of which reentered
the atmosphere, distributing measurable quantities of radioactive
debris. Several other U.S. plutonium heat sources have also
produced accidental releases of radioactive materials.
Proponents note that space reactors hold the promise of dramatic
enhancements in the scope, lifetime and effectiveness of space
exploration activities.
"Space nuclear fission reactor systems could enable exploration
missions requiring substantially greater amounts of electrical
power (on the order of many kilowatts of electricity), where
currently available and reasonably foreseeable energy systems are
likely to be inadequate. The ability to generate high levels of
sustained electrical power regardless of location in the solar
system would permit a new class of missions designed for
longevity, flexibility, and comprehensive scientific
exploration," according to the NASA Federal Register notice.
NORTH KOREA SLAMS THE CONGRESSIONAL RESEARCH SERVICE
The suggestion by a Congressional Research Service analyst that
money from South Korea's Hyundai Group may have been diverted to
support North Korea's nuclear weapons program, noted in
yesterday's Secrecy News, was harshly dismissed by a North Korean
spokesman yesterday.
"Those arguments are not worthy of comment," the spokesman said
before he proceeded to comment.
"Those allegations showed clearly their ignorance and lack of
common sense," the spokesman said, as quoted by Yonhap News
Agency.
"Our nuclear weapons were developed on the base of an independent
economy." So there.
See "N.Korea Dismissed U.S. Claim Funds were Siphoned for Nuke
Program," Yonhap, March 29:
http://tinyurl.com/4ybfo