Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Foreign Policy Commentary
Common Ground Common Sense > National & International News > Op-Ed Articles from the Mainstream Media
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23
Snuffysmith
Stopping Russia - Washington Post editorial

The outbreak of fighting between Russia and the former Soviet republic of Georgia was sudden but not surprising. Conflict has been brewing between Moscow and its tiny, pro-Western neighbor for months. The flashpoints are two breakaway Georgian provinces, Abkhazia and South Ossetia -- the latter being the scene of the latest fighting. The skirmishing and shelling around Georgian villages that prompted Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili to launch an offensive against the South Ossetian capital, Tskhinvali, may or may not have been a deliberate Russian provocation, to which Russia's tank and air assault was the inevitable follow-up. Russian military probes, always denied b y Moscow, have been frequent in recent years. But certainly the deeper source of tension between the two countries is Russia's insistence on maintaining hegemony in the Caucasus. Georgia's democratically elected government has accepted US military and economic aid, supported the mission in Iraq and pursued NATO membership. Moscow will not tolerate such independence - even by a relatively poor country of just 4.6 million people.
Georgia on the Brink - The Times editorial

Yesterday morning Mikhail Saakhashvili, the Georgian President, gave warning that, if reports of Russian armour entering his country were true, it would mean war. They were true. Tanks were crossing the international border from Russia into the breakaway Georgian province of South Ossietia as Mr Saakashvili spoke. He also promised a brief ceasefire to allow the evacuation of wounded civilians. Such ceasefires may come and go. The war may remain officially undeclared. But Russia and its most fervently pro-Western neighbour are now locked in open military conflict.
War in the Caucasus - Wall Street Journal editorial

"War has started," Vladimir Putin said yesterday as Georgian and Russian forces fought over the breakaway Georgian region of South Ossetia. War is certainly what the two countries have seemed to want for some time, and the chances of avoiding a drawn-out conflict now are slim. It's unclear at this stage which side is more at fault for the current fighting. Georgia says it moved on the South Ossetian city of Tskhinvali yesterday after rebels there broke a cease-fire. But President Mikheil Saakashvili has long pledged to retake South Ossetia and another separatist area, Abkhazia, and may have underestimated Moscow's reaction. Within hours, Russian tanks crossed the border to bolster Russian "peacekeepers" who have been stirring up trouble in the two regions. Georgia says Russian airplanes bombed Tskhinvali, reversing some Georgian army gains there, as well as air fields in nonseparatist areas. The Georgian air force claims to have shot down at least five Russian planes. The biggest question now is whether Moscow will simply try to restore the previous status quo in South Ossetia - with Russia and the rebels controlling most of the territory - or go further and crush Georgia while deposing Mr. Saakashvili.
The Bear Lashes Out - New York Post editorial

Both attacks probably were timed to coincide with the Summer Olympics in Beijing, whose lavish opening ceremonies yesterday diverted the world's attention. Tempting though it might be to dismiss the dispute as a purely regional affair, the fighting has the potential for grave international repercussions. The Caucasus region is a significant conduit of oil taken from the Caspian Sea - and any disruption of the oil flow almost certainly would halt the welcome recent fall in crude prices. That, in turn, could reverse the recent drop in prices at the gas pumps. Indeed, the signs are ominous: Russia yesterday charged that Georgia is undertaking "ethnic cleansing" in South Ossetia - a claim that Moscow could well use as a justification for a wider invasion. Georgia, in turn, is appealing for help from Washington - which yesterday stressed its support for "Georgia's territorial integrity."
War Erupts in Georgia - The Economist

On its own, South Ossetia is unlikely to last long. It is a tiny territory run by Russia’s security forces and a small and nasty clique of local thugs who live off smuggling goods and pocketing Russian aid money. According to a Georgian television channel, some 70% of Tskhinvali had been taken by government forces by the end of Friday morning. It appears that Russia will get heavily involved - Russia's president, Dmitry Medvedev, says that he must protect Russian citizens there. The conflict could now quickly spiral into a war between Russian and Georgia, and engulf Abkhazia, a separatist region on the Black Sea coast in which Russia has much more strategic interest.
S. Ossetia Bitterness Turns to Conflict - Steven Eke, BBC News

As heavy clashes are reported in South Ossetia, Russia and Georgia have swapped increasingly angry accusations. Georgia's President Mikhail Saakashvili has called upon his country to "mobilise" in the face of "a very blunt Russian aggression". Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said Moscow had reports of "ethnic cleansing" in villages. Russian tanks have reportedly moved towards the capital of the region, which has been under heavy bombardment from Georgian forces. South Ossetia is a territory one-and-a-half times that of Luxembourg, with an estimated population of some 70,000 people. It is legally part of Georgia, since its self-proclaimed independence has been recognised by no other state, including Russia. Yet its people and their separatist leaders do not want to be part of the Georgian state, in any shape or form.
Georgia's Fait Accompli Failed - Matthew Clements, The Times

Georgia’s main aim in its offensive in South Ossetia appears to have been a swift advance on the separatist capital Tskhinvali to seize Ossetian territory and achieve a fait accompli before Russia is able to respond. The timing may have been chosen to coincide with Vladimir Putin’s visit to Beijing for the Olympic Opening Ceremony. Given Mr Putin’s significant role in Russian foreign policy, Georgia may have hoped that his absence would slow down any Russian response. In the fighting so far, Georgia has used its superiority in artillery and air power to drive the poorly equipped Ossetian forces from villages near Tskhinvali. This has allowed it to surround the city and, barring a short ceasefire so civilians can withdraw, continue its assault.
Georgia Power Play, and Big Gamble - Jim Heintz, Associated Press

Behind the hostilities in South Ossetia are two nations that have long been spoiling for a fight, with Russia eager to show it's boss in the region and US-backed Georgia determined to prove it can stand up to its huge neighbor. With Vladimir Putin in Beijing for the Olympic opening ceremony and the world's attention fixed on China, Georgia may have been betting it could pounce on an opportunity to quickly wrest control of its breakaway province. But the gamble may backfire: Washington hasn't endorsed Georgia's power play, and Moscow's counteroffensive has brought the two sides into a fight it will be hard for Georgia, a former Soviet state, to win. The conflict has great strategic importance because it pits one of Washington's staunchest allies in the war on terror against Russia, a re-emerging superpower with vast energy reserves that is showing growing eagerness to assert its will on the international stage.
Failed Gamble on Russia Not Fighting - O'Flynn and Fletcher, The Times

It looks, in retrospect, like a ruse that went badly wrong. After days of heavy skirmishing between Georgian troops and Russian-backed separatist militias in the breakaway republic of South Ossetia, Mikhail Saakashvili, the Georgian President, went on television on Thursday evening to announce that he had ordered an immediate unilateral ceasefire. Just hours later his troops began an all-out offensive with tanks and rockets to “restore constitutional order” to a region that won de facto independence in a vicious civil war that subsided in 1992. From that moment events began to spiral out of control.
Taunting the Bear - James Traub, New York Times

The hostilities between Russia and Georgia that erupted on Friday over the breakaway province of South Ossetia look, in retrospect, almost absurdly over-determined. For years, the Russians have claimed that Georgia’s president, Mikheil Saakashvili, has been preparing to retake the disputed regions of South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and have warned that they would use force to block such a bid. Mr. Saakashvili, for his part, describes today’s Russia as a belligerent power ruthlessly pressing at its borders, implacably hostile to democratic neighbors like Georgia and Ukraine. He has thrown in his lot with the West, and has campaigned ardently for membership in NATO. Vladimir V. Putin, Russia’s former president and current prime minister, has said Russia could never accept a NATO presence in the Caucasus.
Why this Conflict Matters to the West - Richard Beeston, The Times

It would be a serious mistake for the international community to regard the dramatic escalation of violence in Georgia as just another flare-up in the Caucasus. The names of the flashpoints may be unfamiliar, the territory remote and the dispute parochial, but the battle under way will have important repercussions beyond the region. The outcome of the struggle will determine the course of Russia’s relations with its neighbours, will shape Dmitri Medvedev’s presidency, could alter the relationship between the Kremlin and the West and crucially could decide the fate of Caspian basin energy supplies. Quite what triggered the Georgian offensive, on the day that the world was supposed to gather in peace for the start of the Beijing Olympics, is not yet clear.
Raping Georgia - Ralph Peters, New York Post

As I write, Russian tanks grind into a brave and isolated democratic state. Assuming that the world's attention would focus on Beijing, Moscow stage-managed an elaborate act of aggression against Georgia. But the world has changed since Soviet tanks rolled unchallenged into Afghanistan at Christmastime 29 years ago. Global communications now spotlight aggression instantly. Yesterday, the world didn't watch the Olympic opening ceremonies (the Chinese must be furious at the Russians). Instead, we saw images of Soviet - sorry, I meant Russian - aircraft pounding Georgian territory as Russian armor rolled over the Caucasus Mountains. The Kremlin is determined to break Georgia's will - and keep the feisty republic out of NATO.
How Georgia Fell into its Enemies' Trap - Edward Lucas, The Times

When is a victory not a victory? When it dents your country's image, scares your allies and gets you into an unwinnable war with a hugely stronger opponent. That is the bleak outlook for Georgia this weekend, after what initially looked like a quick military win against the separatist regime in South Ossetia. Georgia's attack followed weeks of escalating provocations, including hours of heavy shelling by the Russian-backed breakaway province and signs of large-scale Russian reinforcement. Thanks to American military aid, Georgia's 18,000-strong armed forces are the best-trained and equipped fighting force in the Caucasus. But it is one thing for them to defeat the raggle-taggle militia of a tinpot place like South Ossetia (population 70,000). It is another for a country of less than five million people to take on Russia (population 142 million). Now the Kremlin is reacting strongly.
World's Rising Powers Strut Their Stuff - Anne Applebaum, Washington Post

For the best possible illustration of why Islamic terrorism may one day be considered the least of our problems, look no further than the BBC's split-screen coverage of Friday's Olympic Opening ceremonies. On one side, fireworks sparkled and thousands of exotically dressed Chinese dancers bent their bodies into the shape of doves, the cosmos and so on. On the other side, grey Russian tanks were shown rolling into South Ossetia, a rebel province of Georgia. The effect was striking: Two of the world's rising powers were strutting their stuff. The difference, of course, is that one event has been rehearsed for years, while the other, if not a total surprise, was not actually scheduled to take place this week. And that, too, is significant: The Chinese challenge to Western power has been a long time coming, and it is in a certain sense predictable. As a rule, the Chinese do not make sudden moves and do not try to provoke crises. Russia, by contrast, is an unpredictable power, which makes responding to Moscow more difficult. In fact, Russian politics have become so utterly opaque that it is not easy to say why this particular "frozen" conflict has escalated now. Russian sources said yesterday that Georgia had launched an invasion of South Ossetia, aiming to pacify the breakaway region. Georgia, meanwhile, said that its troops entered the South Ossetian "capital" in response to escalating attacks, which have been intensifying for a week -- and have been taking place for years, really -- as well as the Russian aerial bombardment of Georgian territory.
Snuffysmith
Georgia Wants U.S. to Restrain Russia: Five days after Georgian troops stormed into South Ossetia to reclaim control of the tiny breakaway territory, they were in retreat on Sunday after being battered by Russian forces. But the Russians have not confined themselves to pushing Georgian forces out of South Ossetia, and ongoing Russian attacks have hit close to the Georgian capital and along its coastline

US condemns 'dangerous' Russian response in South Ossetia: American official calls Moscow's military action against Georgia 'disproportionate' and warns of lasting damage to relations

U.S. suggests Russia wants "regime change" in Georgia: The United States suggested on Sunday that Russia was interested in "regime change" in Georgia after Moscow rejected Tbilisi's offer of a cease-fire in the separatist enclave of South Ossetia.

Georgia: Vladimir Putin leads from front to send US a bullish message: The fighting in Georgia has answered the question that world leaders have been asking since Vladimir Putin stepped down as President this year: who runs Russia?

U.S. has few options to deter Russia: Most of the key cards, including the power to veto any United Nations, were held by Russia, which appeared to be using the crisis to ram home to the United State and its allies that it will not accept further expansion of NATO. Both Georgia and the former Soviet republic of Ukraine are seeking to join the alliance.

Did the U.S. Prep Georgia for War with Russia?: One of the U.S. military trainers put it to me a bit more bluntly. “We’re giving them the knife,” he said. “Will they use it?”

'US incited Georgia offensive in S. Ossetia': The White House has orchestrated the current conflict between Russia and Georgia in South Ossetia, a high-ranking Russian official says. In a Friday press conference, Chairman of Russia's State Duma Security Committee Vladimir Vasilyev said without US aid, Tbilisi would have been unable to start military operation in South Ossetia.

Fact or fiction: Israel 'has a hand in S. Ossetia war': The report added the Israeli advisers were deeply involved in the Georgian army's preparations to attack and capture the capital of South Ossetia on Friday.

Snuffysmith

Georgia: Russia Begins Bombing Russian Capitol

Kim Sengupta, Sean Walker, Independent UK

ForeignPolicy: Georgia's appeal for a ceasefire seemed to have fallen on deaf ears on Sunday as Russian jets bombed Tbilisi for the first time.
Snuffysmith
Edwards sex scandal enrages Huffington Post's female pundits
August 11, 2008
Over at the lefty Huffington Post, John Edwards' confession of being a cheat has, interestingly, provoked fury among some of the gal pundits. More

More rumblings of a Hillary coup
August 11, 2008
Evidence accumulates favoring the possibility of a Hillary coup at the Denver convention, and it is being noticed among the sharper observers of politics. More

Edwards, Rielle Hunter and Andrew Young
August 10, 2008
As the media continues to avert its eyes from the Edwards' scandal, bloggers continue to tell us interesting things about the Democrat's fair haired boy and what was going on in Edwards' camp under the radar. More

Climate Impacts Center to shut down
August 10, 2008
As the Democrats are about to gather in Denver, the famed Climate Impacts Center in neighboring Boulder is being shut down by its parent organization, the National Center for Atmospheric Research More

US and Iraqis Close to Troop Withdrawal Agreement
August 10, 2008
The US and Iraq are moving toward an agreement that would establish a "very clear" timeline for pulling out our troops. This according to the Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshiyar Zebari:In an interview with Reuters, Zebari said the agreement, including the... More

Will McCain Make a 'One and Done" Pledge at RNC?
August 10, 2008
Will John McCain announce at the convention that if elected, he will not run in 2012? More

Iran's unsporting behavior in Beijing
August 10, 2008
Despite the One World One dream Olympic theme, the Iranians have not forsaken their dream of one world without Israel. More

'The coverup is always worse...'
August 10, 2008
Of all places, the Huffington Post is debunking John Edwards' claims during his ABC TV interview - the one he says will be his final word of the subject of his "affair" More

Pak Army to Ask Musharraf to Resign
August 10, 2008
With the Pakistani coalition government ready to begin impeachment proceedings against President Pervez Musharraf, the army has taken it upon themselves to defuse the volatile situation by asking their former Commander in Chief to resign: More

Snuffysmith
NYT logic on Georgia war with Russia
August 11, 2008
Georgia helping US and Iraqis in Iraq helped cause Russian invasion of Georgia, according to the New York Times. More

Understanding the Caucasus
August 11, 2008
Two great sites to help us understand what is going on in the Caucasus More

Russians Continue drive into Georgia
August 11, 2008
Despite pleas for a cease fire from most of the world and Georgia herself, Russian troops have begun what it appears to be a drive to capture the vital rail and highway nexus in the towm of Gori More

More rumblings of a Hillary coup
August 11, 2008
Evidence accumulates favoring the possibility of a Hillary coup at the Denver convention, and it is being noticed among the sharper observers of politics. More

Climate Impacts Center to shut down
August 10, 2008
As the Democrats are about to gather in Denver, the famed Climate Impacts Center in neighboring Boulder is being shut down by its parent organization, the National Center for Atmospheric Research More

US and Iraqis Close to Troop Withdrawal Agreement
August 10, 2008
The US and Iraq are moving toward an agreement that would establish a "very clear" timeline for pulling out our troops. This according to the Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshiyar Zebari:In an interview with Reuters, Zebari said the agreement, including the... More

Will McCain Make a 'One and Done" Pledge at RNC?
August 10, 2008
Will John McCain announce at the convention that if elected, he will not run in 2012? More

Iran's unsporting behavior in Beijing
August 10, 2008
Despite the One World One dream Olympic theme, the Iranians have not forsaken their dream of one world without Israel. More

'The coverup is always worse...'
August 10, 2008
Of all places, the Huffington Post is debunking John Edwards' claims during his ABC TV interview - the one he says will be his final word of the subject of his "affair" More

Pak Army to Ask Musharraf to Resign
August 10, 2008
With the Pakistani coalition government ready to begin impeachment proceedings against President Pervez Musharraf, the army has taken it upon themselves to defuse the volatile situation by asking their former Commander in Chief to resign: More

Snuffysmith
Russia bids to rid Georgia of its folly
The Georgian push into the breakaway region of South Ossetia was not intended to hold it, but to destroy it, ending secession by liquidating its people. The Russian response has put a halt to that, and then some. If a ceasefire follows soon, Georgians and Russians might be able to agree that the unpopular President Mikheil Saakashvili bears responsibility for the war. This will place the United States and France at severe odds. - John Helmer (Aug 11, '08)

Saakashvili overplays his hand
The strategy of Georgia's President Mikheil Saakashvili is clear. His only chance of success in his bid to regain control of the Moscow-backed breakaway region of South Ossetia is to globalize the conflict and turn it into a central front of a new struggle between Moscow and the West. However, he appears to have badly miscalculated the West's willingness - and ability - to intervene.
Snuffysmith
New al-Qaeda focus on NATO supplies
Almost 90% of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization's shipments for Afghanistan land at the southern Pakistani port city of Karachi. Rather than wait for the supplies to reach the border areas, al-Qaeda and Taliban militants now plan to target them in Karachi. Their cause is aided by political turmoil in Islamabad. - Syed Saleem Shahzad (Aug 11, '08)

CAMPAIGN OUTSIDER
The story of O
If a United States presidential candidate shies from an election that is a referendum on him, then maybe he's the wrong candidate. – Muhammad Cohen (Aug 11, '08)

Awe (but no laughter) in Beijing
The opening of the Beijing Olympics was a remarkable spectacle of color, choreography, athleticism and pyrotechnics, received by a local and worldwide audience with gasps and applause. The one think missing was laughter. - Kent Ewing (Aug 11, '08)

SPENGLER
Sufism, sodomy and Satan
Sufism seeks one-ness with the universe through spiritual exercises that lead individual consciousness to dissolve into the cosmos. But nothing is more narcissistic than the contemplation of the cosmos, for if we become one with the cosmos, what we love in the cosmos is simply an idealized image of ourselves. An idealized self-image is also what attracts the aging lecher to the adolescent boy. (Aug 11, '08)

US too much in the dark for Iran strike
An attack on Iran's nuclear facilities cannot be justified, given the limited US knowledge of these, while a strike would probably merely delay Tehran's ability to make a nuclear weapon, according to a US think-tank. It argues that comparisons with previous similar pre-emptive strikes are misleading. - Jim Lobe (Aug 11, '08)
Snuffysmith
All downhill for Pakistan's economy
President Pervez Musharraf may use the country's deteriorating economy, racked by rising prices, withdrawal of foreign funds and a weakening currency, to dissolve parliament. The open fight between president and government will bring even further uncertainty to the economy. - Syed Fazl-e-Haider

Fleeced in the Persian Gulf
Persian Gulf countries' distribution of their vast wealth is desperately skewed, making a few people super-rich while most of the citizenry must struggle to survive amid this pillage and its related corruption and inflation. - Hossein Askari
Snuffysmith
Battle lines move from Kashmir to Kabul
On the surface, India appears to have scored a major diplomatic victory in Afghanistan. This has come with the blessing of the US, which has embarked on an unprecedented pro-India tilt in its regional policy. Washington's other major ally in the region, Pakistan, is naturally not impressed and sees Kabul replacing Kashmir as the main area of antagonism with New Delhi. How Washington benefits from this is unclear, but India would do well to remember the history of its involvement in Afghanistan - and prepare for a Pakistani backlash. - M K Bhadrakumar (Aug 8, '08)

Inside Iran's garden of diplomacy
The United States has dismissed Iran's response to an incentive package offered by world powers to Tehran over its nuclear program as "not a serious answer". The point is, the reply was intended not as an answer but rather as a notification of Iran's willingness to continue negotiations in earnest. Russia appears to understand this. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Aug 8, '08)

Laura Bush's Myanmar crusade
United States First Lady Laura Bush has long been a strident critic of Myanmar's ruling junta. Whether this is genuine or political, ever since she picked up the cudgel there has been more scrutiny of Myanmar - a country that reportedly has more destroyed villages than Darfur and the largest use of children by a government army. - Brian McCartan (Aug 8, '08)

Internet rumors roil China-Korea ties
For web surfers in China and South Korea, less-than-credible Internet news reports lead to tension and nationalism over interpretations of history. Bloggers on both sides claim to be reading more and more incriminating allegations online, but the two sides aren't really communicating at all. - Sunny Lee (Aug 8, '08)

PLAY BY PLAY
Lights, cameras - let's get to the sport
Olympic opening ceremonies have become expensive, overblown melanges of circus and propaganda. While their political importance cannot be denied, what do choreographed dancers, outlandish props and inflated dirigibles have to do with sport? Mercifully, the real theater is set to begin in Beijing. - Jesse Fink (Aug 8, '08)
Snuffysmith

Apply Kosovo's model to South Ossetia?

By Walid Phares


The conflict over South Ossetia -and possibly over Abkhazia's- regions is dangerous development in international stability and particularly for the efforts deployed worldwide in the campaign against Terror forces. For this local ethnic and territorial confrontation, involving now Georgia and the Russian Federation has the potential of absorbing energies and resources, otherwise needed and applied elsewhere in resisting Jihadi offensives and networks.

Georgia is an important ally in the US-led coalition overseeing the stabilization of Iraq and the containing of Khomeinist offensive in that country. An escalation over South Ossetia and Abkhazia will lead (and has already significantly) to a full withdrawal of Georgia from Iraq and eventually drawing US and other Western diplomatic efforts and resources for the defense of Georgia in the Caucuses. This will weaken the position in Iraq, in the Middle East and open an unnecessary front in a different region against a superpower, also drawn into the conflict because of local conflicts.

Russia and the West have a series of disagreement on the "War on Terror" so far. Moscow and Washington didn't see eye to eye in Iraq and are not at ease on the issue of anti-missiles systems in central Europe. It is not wise, strategically to open a military front -via proxies- against the Russian Federation in the Caucuses. While many in Washington and Brussels are still in Cold War mood, we need to realize that present day Russia is also at war with the Jihadi-Wahabi networks. Beyond and above the Chechen crisis, al Qaeda and the Salafi combat movement -chief enemy of the West (US and Western Europe combined) wants Russia down as much as they wish to see liberal democracies defeated. Thus, it is not in the interest of the US-led efforts against worldwide Jihadi forces to engage in a strategic confrontation with Russia, despite all the latter's negative behavior on many issues worldwide. The West needs to rationalize fully at this stage where the so-called "War on terror" is not going extremely well.

Thus it is suggested to move forward and quickly with two main parameters: On the one hand stand by Georgia as a staunch ally of the West and make sure its sovereignty and security are protected. On the other hand stop any potential conflict with Russia in the Caucuses and find a solution which would bring justice to the local parties and encourage Moscow to divert its resources from borders crisis to a world campaign against what is more dangerous to all democracies -old ones and transitional ones. This last effort may not be easy but is crucial if we wish to keep the focus on the greater conflict against Jihadist totalitarianism. Hence, it is suggested to quickly apply in South Ossetia what Americans and Europeans have applied in Kosovo so that local wounds are healed and regional stability is reaffirmed. Here is the model based on the Balkans resolution process.

Read More »


1. South Ossetia and Abkhazia are provinces (self declared Republics) within a sovereign country, Georgia. The populations of these two entities rose to obtain separation based on their own perception of cultural identity. They are the equivalent of Kosovo. An initial confrontation in the early 1990s (1992-1994) led to agreements allowing for local autonomy and deployment of Russian (CIS) Peacekeepers.

2. Tensions related to the will of these provinces to move forward to self determination led to a move by Georgia to assert what it called "constitutional order." In other words, a military initiative to seize back South Ossetia. This in turn triggered a Russian military counter attack to block and reverse the Georgian move. Both parties claim they intervened as a response to a perceived opposing field move. But reality is that Georgian and Russian forces battled over South Ossetia.

3. A Kosovo-like model would be to bring the situation to pre August 6 status quo and move rapidly from there on to apply international law. This means practically that:

a. Georgian forces should withdraw from South Ossetia (equivalent of the Serbian pull-out from Kosovo). A pull out they say they accomplished already.

b. Russian forces should withdraw the forces they brought to South Ossetia after August 6.

c. Russian (and CIS) Peace keepers should stay in their positions and -if the UN Security Council offers- should be reinforced by UN Peace keepers.

d. A process leading to referendum in South Ossetia and Abkhazia should be established by the United Nations. If these provinces wish to stay as autonomous regions inside Georgia, an international mechanism to oversee these negotiations should be established. And if these local "republics" wish to separate -like Kosovo- they too should be granted that wish and helped to achieve independence.

As in the former Yugoslav conflict no final solution would satisfy the emotional, historical and geopolitical feelings and aspirations of all parties with the same degree, but this is the current state of our international law. As Pope Benedict XVI has often remarked, the strongest pillar in international relations must be reciprocity. Therefore as we planted in Kosovo, we need to harvest in South Ossetia, and perhaps elsewhere.

For the international community -and the free world in particular- are facing off with a global, advancing and lethal enemy to all. We're dealing for the next decades with forces that see South Ossetia, Abkhazia, Georgia, Russia, Europe, America and all other democracies as "Kuffars" (infidels) with no distinctions. "Indifels" should see beyond local conflicts and solve ethnic struggles as fast as they can; for the Salafists and the Khomeinists, terror powers of the world, count on kuffar wars to survive and prolong their assault on world Peace. We should be smarter, strategically.

Dr Walid Phares is the director of the Future Terrorism Project at the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies and a visiting scholar at the European Foundation for Democracy. He is the author of The Confrontation: Winning the War against Future Jihad.

« Close It

August 10, 2008 01:52 PM Link
Snuffysmith

Islamic Landscape: South and South East Asia

By Animesh Roul


My paper titled "South Asia: Hotbed of Islamic Terrorism", published in the latest issue of the NBR Analysis (The National Bureau of Asian Research, Vol. 19 (4), August 2008, explores the rising menace of Islamic extremism in South Asia while discussing key terrorist groups, networks, and emerging terrorism trends throughout the region.



South Asia has been confronting the challenge of Islamic extremism for many years. At least four South Asian countries—India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and, most recently, the Maldives (each with large Muslim populations)—are considered hotbeds of Islamic terrorism. In both Pakistan and Bangladesh, radical Islamic forces aim to establish Islamic states based on Islamic laws. This region has the highest concentration of Islamic jihadist groups in the world: a rough estimate is that nearly one hundred Islamic extremist groups and jihadi organizations with cross-border linkages are operating with impunity throughout South Asia. India tops the list with more than 50 active or dormant terrorist tanzeems (organizations). Several anti-India and anti-Hindu Islamic groups fighting in Kashmir are based in Pakistan or Bangladesh. Many of these groups have ties with international jihadi organizations based in Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Uzbekistan, including al Qaeda, the Taliban, and the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan (IMU). This essay explores how South Asian countries, in particular India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh, are grappling with Islamic extremism, especially since the catastrophic events of September 11. This essay identifies major terrorist groups and discusses intricate terror networks, their operational developments, and emerging terrorist trends in three country-specific sections. Despite concerted efforts by government forces, including the U.S.-led campaign in South Asia, Islamic terrorism is on the rise, with a new generation of terrorist leaders taking the reins of jihad in their hands throughout the region. The essay also finds that South Asian terrorist groups increasingly prefer to work collectively, even when there is little ideological convergence among their objectives.


For Full Text
The issue titled Aspects of Islamism in South and Southeast Asia has three papers:

Introduction: Islamism and U.S. Policy in South and Southeast Asia by Robert W. Hefner
South Asia: Hotbed of Islamic Terrorism by Animesh Roul
The Fluid Terrain of Islamism in Southeast Asia by Joseph Chinyong Liow

August 8, 2008 11:56 AM Link
Snuffysmith

China discovers al Qaeda in its backyard

By Walid Phares


In a video accusing China’s Communist Government of “mistreating Muslims” a Jihadi group threatened to attack the Summer Games in Beijin. A spokesman of the Turkistan Islamic Party accuses China of “forcing Muslims into atheism and destroying Islamic schools. The “Turkistan Islamic Party” is most likely based across the border in Pakistan, where sources affirm it received training from Al Qaeda.

Weeks ago the organization claimed responsibility for a bombings across the country. The latest video shows graphics of a burning Olympics logo and explosions. This week, attackers killed 16 police and wounded more than a dozen in the Xinjiang city of Kashgar using homemade bombs.

But according to AP reports few months ago, Chinese Police broke up a terror plot targeting the Beijing Olympics while a flight crew foiled attempt to crash a Chinese plane. Per Communist Party officials in the North Western province of Xinjiang, materials seized in a January 27 raid in the regional capital, Urumqi, suggested the plotters' planned "specifically to sabotage the staging of the Beijing Olympics." Earlier reports said police found guns, homemade bombs, training materials and "extremist religious ideological materials" during the January raid in Urumqi, in which two members of the gang were killed and 15 arrested. The immediate question becomes: Is China targeted by a Terror organization? And since the material found was characterized as “extremist religious ideological”, does that mean it is al Qaeda or one of its affiliate? The answer to these questions could change the face of geopolitics in Asia.

Interestingly the Associated Press runs to frame the Terrorists to a local ethnic conflict in one of China’s Western provinces. AP wrote: “Chinese forces have for years been battling a low-intensity separatist movement among Xinjiang's Uighurs, a Turkic Muslim people who are culturally and ethnically distinct from China's Han majority.” The news agency has tried to set the agenda of the debate by scoring three points for the “radicals.” They are separatists, they are representative of a local ethnicity and they are Muslim. In addition the description of the struggle is informative: Chinese forces versus a Uighur movement. In a way a parallel to Kosovo, Chechnya and Kashmir with two projected effects. As framed by AP, the struggle of these “Terrorists” is indeed legitimate even though the means are violent. But is it the case?

Evidently the Chinese Communists are repressive against all other minorities and political dissidents. But as in Russia and India’s Wahabi cases, one would investigate if these particular Terrorists in China are local patriotic elements with liberal outlook. Not really. As under the Russians in Chechnya it looks like the Communists in China are battling another form of totalitarianism to come: Jihadism.

Read More »


Chinese officials said the group had been trained by and was following the orders of a radical group based in Pakistan and Afghanistan called the East Turkestan Islamic Movement, or ETIM. The group has been labeled a terrorist organization by the United Nations and the United States. East Turkestan is another name for Xinjiang. So the “movement” is indeed Terrorist-identified by the international community. But other than its violent means, is that group linked to al Qaeda? There is a double answer to this question. First the group is indeed Jihadi Wahabi-Salafi as its long term objective is to separate a particular province from China but only to establish an Emirate, a prelude to join the world Caliphate. Hence ideologically it is part of the world web of internationalist Jihadis, who identify with Bin Laden’s school of thought. Second in many instances, al Qaeda produced material showing Chinese Jihadists training in their camps. In the chat rooms, the Salafi commentators often cite the presence of “brothers” from the Xinjiang. And let’s remind ourselves that upon the fall of Tora Bora in 2001, Chinese officials asked US military to extradite Chinese nationals who we part of the Taliban and al Qaeda networks in Afghanistan. So the bottom line is that the Bin Laden cohorts included Jihadis recruited from inside China’s Western province. As in Chechnya a local ethnic separatist claim exists but the struggle was hijacked by the Jihadi terror forces.

Hence as China is discovering al Qaeda in its own backyard, this begs powerful questions:

1. If these Jihadists will escalate their Terror against Chinese cities and installations -and the recent discoveries indicate this trend- will Beijing find itself in the same trench as Washington that is against al Qaeda and the Salafists?

2. And if that becomes the case, will China continue to pursue a policy of support to other Jihadist forces, including the Islamist regime in Khartoum?

3. If Communism and Jihadism clash again in the 21st century inside the Asian superpower, will its resources rich Western province becomes a new Afghanistan with Jihadists converging from central Asia and other parts f the world?

For now Chinese officials are downplaying the danger altogether and dismissing the threat: "Those in Xinjiang pursuing separatism and sabotage are an extremely small number,” said a pro Government Uighur leader. “They may be Uighurs, but they can't represent Uighurs. They are the scum of the Uighurs," regional communist official Bekri said. But that is what Russian officials always said about Chechnya and their Indian counterparts argued about Kashmir. Jihadism has demonstrated that its adherents can swiftly recruit and expand, especially if international Wahabis are generous and committed. Hence the answer to this critical new “Jihad” will come from as far as Pakistan, Saudi Arabia but also from the smaller principality of Qatar, where al Jazeera can transform a local separatist movement into an uprising in the name of the Umma.

***********

Dr Walid Phares is the Director of the Future Terrorism Project at the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies and a visiting scholar at the European Foundation for Democracy. He is the author of The Confrontation: Winning the War against Future Jihad

« Close It

August 7, 2008 10:47 PM Link
Snuffysmith

1998 U.S. Embassy Bombings and Denial on Jihad's Ideology

By Jeffrey Imm


Ten years ago, on August 7, 1998, Al-Qaeda conducted simultaneous car bombings of U.S. embassies in Nairobi, Kenya and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Over 250 died in these attacks, including 10 Americans at the U.S. embassy in Nairobi, and 6000 were reported injured. The August 7, 2008 East African Standard reports that new intelligence reports show that the Al-Qaeda terrorists planned in Nairobi "to use a device twice as big as the one that exploded." The Kenyan Daily Nation reported that 300 of the injured subsequently died. The majority of the victims of the embassy bombings were African civilians.

But despite that terrible human tragedy and the thousands of pages of documents, indictments, reports, and studies on the 1998 embassy bombings, we still have many today who refuse to confront the ideology behind Jihadist terrorism.

On the 10th anniversary of this tragedy, Kenyan Prime Minister Raila sought to reassure Kenyans that "this Government will do everything possible to prevent us from ever again being attacked." The Kenyan Daily Nation further reported that the prime minister also would not face any "specific groups" that might support such a Jihadist ideology. Prime Minister Raila did not offer any initiatives to challenge the ideologies of Islamic supremacism or Islamism that provides the basis for Jihadist action, but instead focused of "extremism" and "disaffection" as the causes for this tragedy.

As reported by the August 7, 2008 Daily Nation, Prime Minister Raila indicated: "But he ruled out the possibility of targeting specific groups on the war on terror, saying it would be counter-productive. 'It would generate the very disaffection and extremism on which terror thrives. It would be sheer madness to target it, or its followers. Kenya will never do so. Our sole target is terrorists.'" The Kenya Broadcasting Corporation also reported: "He dispelled allegations that the terrorists were acting in the name of Islam, or that the government's anti-terror efforts were directed at Muslims. Raila said the whole world knew that Islam was a religion of peace, adding that its very name was derived from peace."

AFP also reported that President Bush observed the anniversary of the attacks by stating that it "reinforces the need to confront the terrorists, to work with our allies to bring them to justice, and to prevent such attacks from happening again." Meantime, the U.S. 2008 National Defense Strategy is based solely on fighting "extremists," in keeping with the DHS/NCTC "terror lexicon" recommendations on not using any terms such as "Jihad," "Islamist," etc.

The alleged Al-Qaeda mastermind of the 1998 embassy bombings, Fazul Abdullah Mohammed, remains at large. In addition, at least seven others named in the embassy bombing indictment are also at large. Four of the Al-Qaeda bombers were sentenced to life in prison in 2001, and two are reportedly being held at Guantanamo Bay detention center (Ahmed Ghailani and Mamdouh Mahmud Salim). The Guardian reported on August 4, 2008 that "Fazul Abdullah Mohammed, who has a $5m bounty from the US on his head, was reported to have left his hideout in the coastal resort town of Malindi shortly before a raid on Saturday night." In an ongoing manhunt in Kenya for Fazul Abdullah Mohammed, police have subsequently arrested five and are seeking another man for questioning.

With the 10th anniversary of the U.S. embassy bombings and ongoing manhunt for Fazul Abdullah Mohammed, Kenyan Daily Nation has been publishing a series of reports that are allegedly from a diary kept by Fazul that was on a laptop captured by the Kenyan authorities. On August 4 and August 5, the Daily Nation published stories "Diary of a terrorist: Fazul's journey to Pakistan," "Fazul's military quest lands him in Afghanistan," and "Fazul joins camp to begin Jihad." In the alleged diary excepts, Fazul reportedly states that he was led to Islamic supremacism by "the Sudanese school of thought [that] emerged... [that] consisted of a mixture of Muslim Brotherhood and Salafist ideas." (This is the same Muslim Brotherhood that Peter Mandaville has urged engagement with in West Point publications and the same Salafists that Matthew Levitt has suggested "have credibility when it comes to deradicalizing others.") In addition, the McClatchy newspaper chain has done a feature article on the Daily Nation's "Diary of a terrorist" series. These "diary" reports could certainly be apocryphal. But legitimate or not, the willingness of the Daily Nation to publish such anti-American screeds without also offering a challenge to the ideology of the Islamic supremacism behind them is troubling.

The alleged diary quotes by embassy bomber Fazul Abdullah Mohammed reportedly include: "We must, of course, raise our children with the love of jihad. We have to raise a new generation with an education totally opposed to the Western education that is imposed on us."

This quote concisely demonstrates the root of the problem with Islamic supremacism in general as a supremacist ideology that rejects values of equality and liberty, and seeks to promote an alternative Islamic supremacist value system. Such Islamic supremacist goals remain the root cause and motivation behind the 1998 U.S. embassy bombings, even though Prime Minister Raila and President Bush don't understand that as they continue to only tactically pursue "extremists" and "terrorists," without ever honestly asking why so many died.

Ten years is a long time to clearly remember such a tragedy.

"Never again" eventually becomes "never mind." Our national outrage at Jihadists and their ideology has transformed into national policies that merely seek to discourage "extremism," and many of our government leaders don't care that no one can define what "extremism" is.

If these are the circumstances 10 years after the 1998 U.S. embassy bombings, will we be having the same discussion on September 11, 2011 as well?




Read More »


Sources and Related Documents:

List of Documents

August 7, 2008 - Daily Nation: Terrorism: Govt pledges more vigilance

August 7, 2008 - Daily Nation: Never again, Raila assures Kenyans on anniversary of embassy bombing

August 7, 2008 - Daily Nation: Memory of August 7 1998 terror attack in Nairobi, ten years on.

August 7, 2008 - Daily Nation: Nairobi's day of horror recalled

August 7, 2008 - Daily Nation: Use al Qaeda's frozen assets to pay blast victims, US court urged

August 7, 2008 - AFP: Bush focuses on Al-Qaeda on anniversary of embassy bombings

August 7, 2008 - US News and World Report: A Grim 10th Anniversary of the Embassy Bombings

August 7, 2008 - Kenya Broadcasting Corporation: Kenyans commemorate 1998 bomb blast

August 7, 2008 - East African Standard: Terror: Shocking CIA report on blast - Al-Qaeda plotted to use a device twice as big as the one that exploded

August 6, 2008 - Daily Nation: How the Nairobi terror attack was planned

August 6, 2008 - Daily Nation: Police seek to quiz man over al-Qaeda network in E. Africa

August 5, 2008 - Kenya Broadcasting Corporation: Five arrested in Fazul terror pursuit

August 4, 2008 - AP: 3 Kenyans deny they hid terror suspect

August 4, 2008 - BBC: Kenya hunts for al-Qaeda fugitive

August 4, 2008 - Guardian: Al-Qaida fugitive gives Kenyan police the slip

FBI Information on Fazul Abdullah Mohammed

August 7, 2008 - McClatchy Newspapers: 'Diary of a terrorist' -- Kenya's Daily Nation newspaper publishing what it claims are excerpts from the diary of the man that the FBI says planned those attacks and others: Fazul Abdullah Mohammed

August 4, 2008 - Daily Nation: Diary of a terrorist: Fazul's journey to Pakistan

August 5, 2008 - Daily Nation: Diary of a terrorist: Fazul's military quest lands him in Afghanistan

August 5, 2008 - Daily Nation: Diary of a terrorist: Fazul joins camp to begin Jihad

U.S. State Department - Bombings in Nairobi, Kenya and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania -- August 7, 1998

PBS: African Embassy Bombings

PBS: African Embassy Bombings - Map

Copy of indictment USA v. Usama bin Laden et al., Center for Nonproliferation Studies, Monterey Institute of International Studies

Wikipedia: 1998 United States embassy bombings - Indictment

Wikipedia: 1998 United States embassy bombings

October 21, 2001 - CNN: Four embassy bombers get life

October 18, 2001 - CNN: Transcript of sentencing hearing: U.S. v. Osama bin Laden

December 31, 2000 - US News and World Report: Putting Terror Inc. on Trial in New York -- The case against bin Laden's alleged followers

November 15, 1998 - US News and World Report: On Terrorism's Trail -- How the FBI unraveled the Africa embassy bombings -- by David E. Kaplan and Stefan Lovgren

August 28, 1998 - Electronic Telegraph: US takes custody of two embassy bomb suspects

August 8, 1998 - Electronic Telegraph: 80 killed in US embassy bombings

Wikipedia: Ahmed Ghailani

Wikipedia: Mamdouh Mahmud Salim

Wikipedia: Fazul Abdullah Mohammed

July 2, 2008 - Crossroads in History: The Struggle against Jihad and Supremacist Ideologies -- Counterterrorism Blog - by Jeffrey Imm

June 2008 - U.S. National Defense 2008 document (PDF)

June 2008 - West Point Combating Terrorism Center (CTC) Sentinel: "Engaging Islamists in the West" by Peter Mandaville (page 5)

July 17, 2008 - The Way Back from Islamism -- Counterterrorism Blog - by Matthew Levitt

March 14, 2008 - National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC) - Counterterror Communications Center (CTCC) Memorandum, Volume 2, Issue 10 - "Words that Work and Words that Don't: A Guide to Counterterrorism Communication"

January 2008 - Department of Homeland Security Office for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties - Terminology to Define the Terrorists: Recommendations from American Muslims



« Close It

August 7, 2008 09:42 PM Link
Snuffysmith
Georgia's War is War for the West - Mikheil Saakashvili, Wall Street Journal
Don't Turn Georgia into Another Sarajevo - W. Rees-Mogg, The Times
Putin Makes His Move - Robert Kagan, Washington Post
Learning the Right Lessons From 1936 - Samuel Chi, RealClearWorld
A City's Olympics Come to Life - Geremie Barme, Sidney Morning Herald
Snuffysmith
Breaking the Cyprus Deadlock by Patrick Seale
A unified Cyprus would undoubtedly be good for Europe, for Turkey, and for Greek-Turkish relations. It would also provide a model of peaceful reconciliation to the warring parties in the Middle East.
more...

The Importance of Iran by Rami G. Khouri
The American-European-led diplomatic minuet with Iran is the most interesting and significant political dynamic in the world today. What happens on the Iran issue will determine power relations for years to come -- far beyond Iran’s immediate neighborhood.
more...

Collapse of the Middle East Peace Process by Patrick Seale
Under the faltering sponsorship of U.S. President George W. Bush, no progress can be expected for the next several months until new leaders emerge in both Israel and the United States.
more...

Palestinian Kids Who Conquer Tree Houses by Rami G. Khouri
This is a dark day for the Palestinians, but not the end of the line. When they hit bottom -- and they are almost there -- the Palestinians will find better leadership that can regain their cohesion and credibility, and their self-respect.
more...

Ten Principles for US Policy in the Middle East by Rami G. Khouri
Rami Khouri has been in Washington in recent months, talking with friends and colleagues, and generating a list of ten principles and policies that should define American policies in the Middle East.
more...

Turkey's Narrow Escape by Patrick Seale
Turkey’s Constitutional Court decided on 30 July not to close down the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) and not to ban its leaders from politics for their alleged “anti-secular activities.”
more...

Afghanistan: Shoals Ahead for President Obama by Immanuel Wallerstein
Obama is riding high on his position on the Iraq war, and will reap credit from the U.S. and world public for his stance. But he can undo that credit by failing to deliver on an impossible promise concerning Afghanistan.
more...
Snuffysmith

Georgia Tries out the Bush War Doctrine, Loses Badly

By Gary Brecher, eXiled Online

ForeignPolicy: The president of tiny Georgia must have caught a case of his pal Bush's war lust to attack a Russian ally and think he'd win.
Snuffysmith
The end of the post-Cold War era

The United States is carefully cultivating an opinion in Western capitals that Russia is "bullying" Georgia. This will strengthen Washington's case for inducting Georgia into the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, which will in turn facilitate the deployment of the US missile defense system onto Russia's border. If Moscow remains passive, the Caucasus could become its "bleeding wound". - M K Bhadrakumar (Aug 12, '08)

Russia marks its red lines
The Georgian attack on South Ossetia and the Russian response is the first battle in a new proxy war between United States and Israeli interests against Russia. But Georgia and ally Washington appear to have miscalculated very badly. Russia has made it clear it has no intention of ceding its support for South Ossetia or allowing a missile defense system into a neighboring country. - F William Engdahl (Aug 12, '08)

Oil in troubled mountains
The Caucasus conflict underlines the exposed position of oil pipelines from the Caspian Sea that avoid Russia by threading their way through Georgia. Moscow's military moves, supposedly over South Ossetia, indicate its intention to maintain control of these energy links to the West. - Robert M Cutler (Aug 12, '08)

SPENGLER
Putin for US president
- more than ever

Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's swift and decisive action in Georgia reflects precisely the sort of decisiveness that America requires. However, the United States, apart from a bad case of cream pie in the face, has lost nothing in this flare-up - Georgia never should have been an ally anyway. (Aug 12, '08)
Snuffysmith
China's slowdown in growth to continue
China's economic growth is set to slow further as global woes, including rising prices, make more inroads, even as the government seeks to stabilize growth. - Olivia Chung

Lee's pardons send
mixed message

South Korean business groups welcomed the government pardon of company executives, including Hyundai Motor chairman Chung Mong-koo, convicted for a range of corporate offences. Others said President Lee Myung-bak's decision demonstrated to foreign investors the inequity of the country's business environment.
Snuffysmith

Charging the Victim: Who Should Pay to Rebuild Iraq?
by Ed Kinane / August 11th, 2008

Our Congressional Representative James Walsh (R-NY) recently “lashed out at Iraq.” Walsh, now in his tenth term, said Iraq should use its oil windfall sales to repay some of the $48 billion the United States has spent “rebuilding” there.

“We have delivered democracy for them… The least they could do is step up to the plate and help out,” Walsh opined.“Walsh: Iraq should use oil sales windfall to repay US” by Mark Weiner of the Syracuse, New York Post-Standard, 8 Aug. 2008.

Let’s not look too closely at that “democracy” we’ve “delivered.” Let’s not ask to what extent bombed-out medical …

(Full article …)
Snuffysmith

“Medaling” with Free Speech at the Olympics
by Walter Brasch / August 12th, 2008

President Bush sounded just like a liberal.

Yes, you read that right. Bush. Liberal. Same sentence.

At the new U.S. embassy in Beijing on the opening day of the Olympics, he said, “All people should have the freedom to say what they think.” Without even blinking, he also told the world, while directing his comments at the Chinese, “We strongly believe societies which allow the free …

(Full article …)
Snuffysmith

Georgia on Our Mind
by Jeff Berg / August 12th, 2008

In a nutshell the role of Georgia for the West is to allow it to access Caspian basin energy while bypassing Russia and Iran. Something that quite simply can’t be done without Georgia’s acquiescence.

There is certainly a certain degree of rational sense in the European and U.S. desire for this outcome. I.e. Why not lessen your energy dependence on any single source, in this case Russia, if you possibly can? Diversification is hardly evil by definition. For Russia on the other hand the desire to maximize their involvement in the evolving Caspian energy matrix is a …

(Full article …)
Snuffysmith

The U.S. Government and News Media Are Lying, Again
by Pavel Yakovlev / August 12th, 2008

I lost all faith in the American democratic system and its media when President Bush initiated a false war against Iraq and got away with it. This time, the U.S. media and Bush Administration are lying about a different war — the one between Georgia and Russia. To understand the complex nature of this conflict, a brief review of history is necessary.

Throughout its long history, Georgia, the country, has had difficult relations with Russia and its other neighbors, including the ethnically different Ossetians. Georgians and Ossetians did not always get along. In one instance, Georgian leaders asked the Russian …

(Full article …)
Snuffysmith

Irresponsible Risk Takers in Command
by Rodrigue Tremblay / August 12th, 2008

War prosperity is like the prosperity that an earthquake or a plague brings.

War… is harmful, not only to the conquered but to the conqueror.

To defeat the aggressors is not enough to make peace durable. The main thing is to discard the ideology that generates war.

The root of the evil is not the construction of new, more dreadful weapons. It is the spirit of conquest.

– quotations from Ludwig von Mises (1881-1973)

There are people in charge who think that provocation and aggression can be acceptable government policy. The sudden conflict between the former Soviet province of Georgia and Russia in …

(Full article …)
Snuffysmith
War in the Caucasus: Towards a Broader Russia-US Military Confrontation? - by Michel Chossudovsky - 2008-08-10 Georgia was "encouraged" by NATO and US military officials.
Snuffysmith
A Path to Peace in the Caucasus - Mikhail Gorbachev, Washington Post
The Failure of Realpolitik - Alexander Golts, Moscow Times
Turkey's Abandonment of the West - Caroline Glick, Jerusalem Post
End Sham of African Democracy - Murithi Mutiga, The Independent
Games Have Little Economic Impact on China - Wei Ai, Taipei Times
Snuffysmith
Caucasus War and Balance of Power - George Friedman, RealClearWorld
World Must Unite to Condemn Russia - David Cameron, The Telegraph
Georgia Caused This War - Vadim Mukhanov, Moscow Times
China Grows Faster, Higher, Stronger - James Dorn, Far East. Econ. Review
How Gaza Kids Spend Their Vacation - Mike McNally, Pajamas Media
Snuffysmith
Georgian leader's future in doubt
As soon as the crisis in Georgia subsides, President Mikheil Saakashvili faces a bruising political battle over his role in precipitating the events that led to the bloody confrontation with Russia. Central to this will be whether he deliberately overestimated the West's support for his actions. (Aug 14, '08)

An inevitable clash
The conflict in Georgia marks the dangerous intersection of a heedless North Atlantic Treaty Organization policy of expansion into former Soviet Union republics and a timeless Russian mindset that fears invasion. Neither factor is likely to change: the regional situation can only get worse. - Brian M Downing (Aug 14, '08)
Snuffysmith
China's tough Xinjiang policy backfires
Through propaganda and crackdowns, Chinese authorities have contained simmering ethnic resentment in the western province of Xinjiang, but recent attacks have Beijing concerned that tough measures and tight control are driving disaffected Uyghurs to join the global jihadi movement in Pakistan and Afghanistan. (Aug 14,
Snuffysmith
US blamed for Iran's clout in Iraq
Despite instances of positive assistance from Iran, many Iraqis blame Tehran for meddling in Iraq's politics and corrupting local governments. Others, specifically in Sunni-dominated Diyala province, feel the Iranian influence would have been impossible without United States policies. - Ahmed Ali and Dahr Jamail (Aug 14, '08)
Snuffysmith
Russia's War is the West's Challenge - Mikheil Saakashvili, Washington Post
Putin Checkmates the West - Michael Binyon, Times of London
Georgia War: A Neocon Election Ploy? - Robert Scheer, The Nation
A Reality Check for NATO - Robert Fox, The Guardian
After the Games, Tibet - Nicholas Kristof, New York Times
Snuffysmith
At A Crossroads with Syria
Interview by Daniel Luban | Posted August 12, 2008
Middle East expert Joshua Landis describes U.S. policy on Syria as the “fulcrum between the remaining neoconservative influence in Washington and the rising tide of realists.” In an interview with Right Web, he talks about how opportunities for piloting peace in the Middle East are slipping by as the Bush administration watches from the sidelines, how the White House’s “stubborn, counterproductive” policy on Syria is endangering U.S. soldiers in Iraq, how the neoconservatives have “failed miserably”—and what the best way forward is. Peace Not Near on Middle East’s “Time Horizon”
By Leon Hadar | July 30, 2008
The Bush administration’s symbolic concessions on Iran may be a smokescreen for plausible deniability, and recent diplomatic steps taken by various Middle Eastern players should not be confused with a search for peace. The Middle East is a place where nothing is what it seems to be, where yesterday’s enemy is tomorrow’s ally, where commitments are made to be broken, and where “peace” is nothing more than a long cease-fire.

Snuffysmith
North Korea: Hand-Wringing over Success
By John Isaacs | July 24, 2008
President Bush’s announcement in late June that the United States was taking North Korea off the sponsors of terrorism list thanks to Pyongyang’s progress in dismantling its nuclear weapons program was the culmination of a shift in administration policies that has astonished the world. The shift toward diplomacy has also infuriated many of the administration’s erstwhile supporters who, in John Bolton’s words, have begun to bemoan the “final collapse of Bush's foreign policy.”

Blackwater: The Real “Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy”?
By Ali Gharib | July 18, 2008
Businessmen with ties to the GOP and right-wing ideologies and pedigrees are not uncommon. What makes Erik Prince special is the confluence of his core beliefs—militarism, right-wing Christianity, and privatization—in his controversial mercenary business, Blackwater Worldwide. At the center of a heated scandal over abuses committed by private military contractors in Iraq and elsewhere, Blackwater has begun to expand its business into intelligence gathering and a host of other security-related services. Its success is helping fill the coffers of some of the country’s most influential conservative political figures and prompting some observers to call it the “future of war.”

Snuffysmith
ANDREW BACEVICH
The Lessons of Endless War tomdispatch.com — To appreciate the full extent of the military crisis into which the United States has been plunged requires understanding what the Iraq War and the Afghan War have to teach. Thus far, the lessons drawn from America's post-9/11 military experience are the wrong ones.

ANATOL LIEVEN
The West Shares The Blame For Georgia ft.com — The bloody conflict over South Ossetia will have been good for something, at least, if it teaches the West not to make promises that it neither can, nor will, fulfill when push comes to shove.

JOE CONASON
A Cut-and-Paste Foreign Policy truthdig.com — The discovery that John McCain's remarks on Georgia were derived from Wikipedia is, to put it politely, disturbing and even depressing but not surprising. Under the tutelage of the neoconservatives, who revealed their superficial understanding of Iraq both before and after the invasion, he favors bellicose grandstanding over strategic thinking. So why delve deeper than a quick Google search?

DR. C.A. ROTWANG
I Wonder Who's Kissinger Now tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com — The irony is that George Bush, in his zeal to extend the U.S. imperial reach, has actually crippled it for the foreseeable future. The provocation of 9/11 has bogged down the U.S. in the big muddy of Iraq, a misadventure which has failed to resolve the ongoing distraction of Al Qaeda's machinations in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

MARK AMES
The War We Don't Know thenation.com — Up until now, this war was framed as a simple tale of Good Helpless Democratic Guy Georgia versus Bad Savage Fascist Guy Russia. In fact, it is far more complex than this, morally and historically. There are two concentric David and Goliath narratives here.
Snuffysmith
Geopolitical Chess: Background to a Mini-war in the Caucasus by Immanuel Wallerstein
It appears that the United States has been sorely mistaken in assuming it has some kind of superpower privilege in its game of geopolitical chess with Russia.
more...

Crisis Looms in U.S.-Pakistan Relations by Patrick Seale
The U.S. “war on terror” against the Taliban not going well, political hustings in the United States and Pakistan (with the possible impeachment of Musharraf) and Pakistan’s concerns about India, all factor into a growing problematic relationship.
more...

Ain’t No Sisters on the Team by Mona Eltahawy
It is time for the Olympics Executive Board to insist Saudi Arabia abides by the IOC charter, which bans discrimination of any kind.
more...

Timely American Wisdom by Rami G. Khouri
The next American administration will have a timely, honest and very practical handbook. The United States Institute of Peace (USIP) has just published a compact but rich little book entitled Negotiating Arab-Israeli Peace: American Leadership in the Middle East.
more...

Breaking the Cyprus Deadlock by Patrick Seale
A unified Cyprus would undoubtedly be good for Europe, for Turkey, and for Greek-Turkish relations. It would also provide a model of peaceful reconciliation to the warring parties in the Middle East.
more...

The Importance of Iran by Rami G. Khouri
The American-European-led diplomatic minuet with Iran is the most interesting and significant political dynamic in the world today. What happens on the Iran issue will determine power relations for years to come -- far beyond Iran’s immediate neighborhood.
more...

Collapse of the Middle East Peace Process by Patrick Seale
Under the faltering sponsorship of U.S. President George W. Bush, no progress can be expected for the next several months until new leaders emerge in both Israel and the United States.
more...
Snuffysmith
Putin's Belligerence Masks Vulnerability - Philip Stephens, Financial Times
Georgia's Recklessness - Paul Saunders, Washington Post
Iraq Must Pay Its Own Way - Linda Bilmes & Joseph Stiglitz, LA Times
Olympic Fatigue - Gordon Chang, Far Eastern Economic Review
Pakistan's Charlatans of Democracy - Fatima Bhutto, The Guardian
Snuffysmith
CHAN AKYA
Utterly pointless Europe
The utter pointlessness of Europe's existence was driven home by a combination of political, strategic and economic developments this week. Far from being a counterweight to the United States or a center of power on its own merit, Europe has turned out to be merely a vestigial organ. Russia is right to take advantage of this mess. (Aug 15, '08)

The bear is back
With Georgia left to deal with the might of Russia's military machine on its own, many of the former communist states can be expected to question the benefits of pursuing close diplomatic, economic and military ties with the United States, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and the European Union. - Richard M Bennett (Aug 15, '08)
Snuffysmith
Peace falls to pieces in the Philippines
The Supreme Court in the Philippines is reconsidering its initial decision to abort a government peace deal with forces of the insurgent Moro Islamic Liberation Front. The separatist rebels have their guns at the ready should the deal not be put back on track, but even if it is, there is a long road ahead. - Noel Tarrazona (Aug 15, '08)

The Olympics as a political arena
Since 420 BC, when Sparta and Arcadia used the Olympics as a diversion to attack neighboring Greece, the Games have been a political and social instrument. A Sudanese refugee as a flag-bearer for the US team and a nine-year-old earthquake survivor marching with the Chinese contingent keep the tradition going. - Dallas Darling (Aug 15, '08)

Security fears paralyze Kabul
A summer of rising insurgent violence and suicide bombings has prompted Afghan police to shut down nearly half of Kabul's major roadways. Many blame the ubiquitous checkpoints and constantly closed roads for slumping business - and the heightened security does not make them feel safe. (Aug 15, '08)

DISPATCHES FROM AMERICA