Conservatives' Bailout Blame Game Yesterday, in a 205-228 vote, the House
failed to pass the Wall Street bailout package, leading to a 777 point drop in the Dow Jones Industrial Average and an overall nine percent drop in stocks -- "
the worst single-day drop in two decades." Despite the passionate urging of House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH), Republicans
voted nearly two-to-one against the deal, dooming it to failure. The New York Times reports that "lawmakers on both sides pointed to an outpouring of opposition from deeply hostile constituents," as "House members in potentially tough races and those seeking Senate seats fled in droves." The vote "
marked a dark moment in a month that has shaken the financial system to its core and forced the government to take a host of ad hoc measures to shore up confidence." Yesterday evening, the Australian stock market
plunged more than five percent in the first 30 minutes of opening, to close with a
$55 billion loss. Immediately following the House vote, the minority leadership held a news conference to start pinning the blame, pointing the finger at House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) for allegedly making an overly "
partisan speech" on the floor before the vote. The move followed a pattern conservatives have adopted of blaming everyone from illegal immigrants to
community organizers -- all while refusing to acknowledge the role that conservative
deregulate-at-all-costs policies played in creating the financial crisis.
BLAME IT ON PELOSI: Immediately after the failed vote, some House conservatives declared the failure Pelosi's fault. "Right here is the reason why this vote failed," Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA) said, holding up a copy of the speech before the television cameras. "[T]his is Speaker Pelosi's speech that, frankly, struck the
tone of partisanship that was inappropriate in this discussion." An aide to Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) called Pelosi's floor speech "
one of the most reckless acts I've seen from a congressional leader in twenty years on the Hill." In fact, Pelosi condemned the "
unbridled" free market that "some in the Republican party, not all" support and also
praised her "Republican colleagues" for working so diligently on the bill. Rep. Barney Frank (D-MA) ridiculed the blame game: "Because somebody hurt their feelings,
they decide to punish the country." Frank added, "I'll make an offer. Give me those 12 people's names and I will go talk uncharacteristically nicely to them and tell them what wonderful people they are and maybe they’ll now think about the country." Other conservatives also rejected the idea that Pelosi's speech colored their votes. "
We are not babies who suck their thumbs," Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) said. Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA) called the idea that Pelosi's speech changed votes "
ridiculous."
BLAME IT ON THE CRA: For weeks, conservatives have blamed the 1977
Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), a bill aimed at helping minorities and low-income Americans obtain mortgages, for somehow causing today's crisis. Blaming the CRA has become a
favorite conservative talking point, peddled recently by
Charles Krauthammer,
Fox News, the
Wall Street Journal, the
Washington Times, and the
National Review. Conservatives often move from
blaming the CRA to blaming minorities themselves. Fox News's Neil Cavuto faulted the CRA's encouraging of "
loaning to minorities and other risky folks." Bachmann last week criticized attempts to push "
homeownership as a way to open the door for blacks and other minorities to enter the middle class." In response, Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN) and other Congressional Black Caucus members wrote to Boehner asking whether all conservatives believe that "
it was lending to minority communities that caused the financial crisis." Ellison also pointed out that the CRA applies only to commercial banks, not independent mortgage companies, which created the majority of subprime loans. "The fact is,
CRAs probably reduced the impact of this problem because they limited the ability for a subprime loan to be issued through banks because they were regulated," he said. As the Center for American Progress's Robert Gordon has noted, "[T]he
real problems came from the institutions beyond the reach of the CRA." CRA institutions engaged in less dangerous lending, as independent mortgage companies "made high-priced loans at
more than twice the rate of the banks and thrifts."
BLAME IT ON UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS: Perhaps the most absurd finger-pointing came from far-right commenter Michelle Malkin, who insisted that "
illegal immigration, crime-enabling banks, and open-borders Bush policies fueled the mortgage crisis." She continued, "Half of the mortgages to Hispanics are subprime (the accursed species of loan to borrowers with the shadiest credit histories). A quarter of all those subprime loans are in default and foreclosure." She quoted a Washington Post report noting that "Hispanics...have been courted aggressively by real estate agents, mortgage brokers and programs," implying no difference between Hispanics and undocumented immigrants.
Rep. Virgil Goode (R-VA) declared "the most important thing" the "government needs to do to stop the financial crisis...is to '
stop encouraging loans to persons who cannot afford to pay them back' -- including illegal immigrants." The Center for American Progress's David Abromowitz slammed Malkin's ridiculous claims. He pointed out that 56 percent of subprime loans went to non-Hispanic whites, while "Hispanics constituted 14 percent of the borrower community and received 20 percent of the subprime loans." "In other words, the vast majority of borrowers getting subprime loans -- and therefore most of those going into default --
were not Hispanics, let alone illegal immigrants." Abromowitz concluded, "
This predictable 'blame the Hispanics' rhetoric would all be so laughable if we didn't have an astoundingly dangerous economic situation rooted in plunging home values and foreclosures facing America today."