Here Are Five Things Democrats Won't Tell You: Caroline Baum
Commentary by Caroline Baum

Sept. 2 (Bloomberg) -- The Democrats have concluded their quadrennial love fest in Denver, inspired by their new standard bearer, united against a common enemy (President
George W. Bush) and confident of victory in November.
And why not? The animosity toward Bush is so great it would take a major gaffe to keep
Barack Obama out of the White House.
That doesn't mean the Democrats won't rise to the challenge.
Presidential campaigns are full of lofty rhetoric and pie- in-the-sky promises. The nominee aspires to restore America's image in the world, fix the economy, feed the hungry, care for the sick, and do it all while balancing the
budget.
Governing is rife with realities: natural disasters, recessions, inconvenient wars all compete for a share of the
federal budget.
Why burden the voters with the facts? There's plenty of time for that later.
For those who like to think ahead, here are five things the Democrats won't tell you. (I'll get to the GOP's non-truths after their convention.)
1. Government can't ``fix'' the economy.
A recent Obama TV ad juxtaposes
John McCain's comments (from January) that the economy isn't headed into recession with those of ordinary Americans telling us how bad things are. It ends with, ``How Can John McCain Fix the Economy When He Doesn't Think It's Broken?''
The implication is that Obama knows and can fix it.
The economy may be broken, 3.3 percent second-quarter growth notwithstanding. Employment is falling, average
incomes aren't keeping up with inflation and credit channels are clogged.
That doesn't mean the government can fix it. The first stimulus package of tax rebates came and went with little impact. Yes, consumers
spent more this summer than they would have without the rebates, but someone else will spend less later.
No matter how the government dresses them up, these are ``transfer payments.'' They transfer purchasing power from the government (i.e., the taxpayer) to folks who may or may not pay taxes. There is no stimulus there. It's a transfer of money from one pocket to the other.
Obama wants to provide $50 billion of ``stimulus'' -- just to ``
jumpstart'' the economy. That's $50 billion that won't be available for the private sector.
Democrats should attend an Alanon meeting and familiarize themselves with the three C's: I didn't cause it, I can't control it, I can't cure it.
2. Healthcare is not a right.
Senator
Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts, undergoing treatment for brain cancer, left his hospital bed to speak to the delegates gathered in Denver. He told the audience he had ``new hope'' the U.S. could guarantee every American ``decent, quality, affordable health care as a fundamental right and not a privilege.''
Universal health care may be a noble goal, but it is not a right. Rights are ``inalienable,'' which means they can neither be granted nor taken away by government.
A right imposes no duty on anyone else, according to an essay by
Charles W. Baird in ``Cliches of Politics,'' a wonderful collection of
essays upending old socialist saws, published by the Foundation for Economic Education. (It was originally published as ``Cliches of Socialism.'')
We can all exercise our rights simultaneously. ``Any time a right claimed by anyone imposes a duty on another to undertake positive action,'' it's not a right, according to Baird.
The Democrats are famous for inventing new rights: a right to an education, a right to a job, a right to a minimum wage.
Applying our definition, do any of these qualify as rights? Right, I mean correct.
If Congress wants to enact universal health care, fine. But don't confuse a privilege with a right.
3. Government doesn't create jobs.
One of the ways Obama aims to fix the economy is by creating ``
New Jobs Through Infrastructure Investment,'' according to his Web site. Many of those jobs will be ``green.''
The government has three ways of financing investment in jobs or anything else: It can tax, borrow or print money.
One lesson of the Great Depression was that every job created by the New Deal, financed by higher
taxes, meant less money for consumers to spend on goods and services, which retarded private-sector job growth.
Government borrowing saps funds available for lending to businesses. Less-efficient government jobs are created in place of private ones.
And as for printing money to pump up spending in the short run, presumably even politicians understand the limits of this strategy.
4. You know all those promises? We can't pay for them.
In his Aug. 28 acceptance speech, Obama promised ``to cut taxes for 95 percent of all working families.'' That's not as easy as it sounds.
``It's almost impossible to deliver tax relief to the working class because they hardly pay anything,'' says
Pete Sepp, vice president for communications at Washington's National Taxpayers Union.
``The effective federal income tax rate for the bottom two quintiles is negative,'' Sepp says, pointing to a Congressional Budget Office
study.
The bottom 50 percent of
tax filers (adjusted gross income under $32,000) earned 15 percent of the income and paid less than 3 percent of the income taxes in 2006, according to the
Internal Revenue Service.
At the other extreme, the top 1 percent of filers (AGI over $389,000) accounted for 21 percent of the income earned and almost 40 percent of the taxes paid.
If the rich are getting richer, ``it's not because the tax system hasn't tried to redistribute income,'' he says.
Obama plans to pay for new spending, including what Sepp says are ``refundable tax credits that exceed the tax liability,'' by raising taxes on the wealthy, closing corporate loopholes and tax havens, and going ``through the federal budget line by line'' to eliminate wasteful and inefficient programs.
He'll need a sharp pencil. Mandatory spending on programs such as Social Security and Medicare are consuming an ever-larger share of the budget and the economy, leaving less for congressional appropriations.
5. We really are sorry Obama beat Hillary.
(
Caroline Baum, author of ``Just What I Said,'' is a Bloomberg News columnist. The opinions expressed are her own.)
To contact the writer of this column:
Caroline Baum in New York at
cabaum@bloomberg.net.